Tag Archives: online advertising

Advice for startups on how to make money from online advertising

Over the past few months, a number of Canadian online media startups have asked me for advice on how to make money from online advertising. The most common question I get is “when does it make sense to start selling ads on my website and how do I do that?”

Since so many digital startups want to know, I thought it would make sense to provide some helpful steps to take and options to consider:

1. Determine your monthly unique visitor traffic
Typically, advertisers (and their agencies) won’t be interested in buying premium ads on your website until you’ve hit a certain traffic threshold. That threshold may vary depending on how niche your content is. However, I would suggest that 50,000 unique monthly visitors is likely a good benchmark.

Until you reach that threshold, I recommend thinking about alternatives like sponsorships, content integration, affiliate partnerships, barter deals, and Google Ad Sense instead. See my notes below on  these opportunities.

Advertisers usually want  to see data from third-party online media measurement companies, rather than your back-end data from Google Analytics or Omniture. In Canada, they typically look to comScore Media Metrics for that data. In the US, they will look to comScore, Neilsen or Compete. If you cannot afford to purchase reports from these companies, DoubleClick Ad Planner gives you a good third-party estimate of your traffic.

2. Calculate what your traffic is worth
I would recommend that you calculate the potential advertising revenue of your website before deciding whether it’s time to start selling ads directly to advertisers. This will help you to determine the cost benefit of putting a lot of resources behind selling, managing and reporting on ad campaigns versus selling sponsorships, working with Google Ad Sense or being represented by an ad network.

A quick way to do this is to look at the total number of pageviews that you have on your website. Then, estimate the number of ad units that you will have on most of your pages. A good estimate is roughly 1.5 ad units per page (because you may have one or two premium ad units on a page, plus one or two additional ad units that may not be in a premium position).

A lot of publishers use an average CPM of around $12.00 to do their estimates. That is because there will be some ad inventory on your website that could be worth $30.00 per thousand impressions (CPM). However, a lot of it will only be worth $3.00 – $5.00, depending on placement.

Also, be aware that when you are starting out, there will be a ramp up period for getting advertisers to pay premium dollars to be on your website. Be prepared that you may not get your desired premium CPM until there is enough demand for your content.

So, the formula should look like this: (X number of pageviews x 1.5 x 12) / 1,000. This gives you a rough estimate of what your inventory is likely worth and is a good starting point for figuring out your next move.

3. Flat fee sponsorships
If your traffic is currently below the suggested traffic threshold, you may want to consider selling a flat fee sponsorship. That’s because it will likely end up costing you more to do the work to manage the ad campaigns that you sell, than what the advertiser will ultimately be willing to pay for your inventory. I recommend that you charge a flat fee for a sponsorship for all or a particular segment of the content on your website. That way, you can leave it up on your website for a set period of time and not worry about as much manual labour.

If you are planning a special feature or promotion for your website, I recommend that you seek out an advertiser who would be interested in co-branding or sponsorship opportunities, or even possible barter deals. In addition, eNewsletter sponsorships can get you a decent CPM. However, the key is to have a big distribution list. So, start building up an e-mail user base now and get people to opt-in for future e-mail messages from sponsors.

4. Google Ad Sense
There are pros and cons to putting Google Ad Sense ads on your website. The pro is that you can start to make money right away from the inventory on your website.

The con is that it makes it tougher for you to convince advertisers to buy premium ads with you. That’s because they can buy ads via the Google Content Network on your website for a cheaper CPM. You need to decide what works best for you. However, it often makes sense to put your remnant, or unsold advertising inventory into an ad network or ad exchange.

5. Affiliate partnerships
Another option that you can consider is making money for sending traffic and leads to other websites to help them drive sales. This is called affiliate partnerships. If you have very niche content that caters to a specific type of customer (i.e. beauty tips, mortgage rates, etc.), then certain related businesses may be interested in developing an affiliate program with you.

This means that you can potentially share revenue with them from the sale on their website. Or, they might pay you on a cost-per-lead basis. It’s worth investigating potential affiliate partners in the industry in which your website is serving.

6. Ad Network Representation
When you are just starting out, it can be tempting to seek out advertising network representation. Ad networks will also want to know if you’ve met a certain traffic and page view threshold before they decide whether they will want to represent your website. In terms of page views, you’re likely going to be appealing to a direct sales ad network if you have reached roughly 500,000 monthly page views or more (even better if it’s closer to 1 million).

Once again, there are pros and cons to having a larger ad network handle the advertising sales on your behalf.

The pro is that if you do not have the expertise or resources to go out and sell the inventory yourself, you can have someone else handle it while you focus on growing your business and the traffic to your website.

The con is that you will likely have to share up to 50% of the revenue with the ad network. This is because you do not have enough traffic volume at this time to justify a bigger revenue share model for yourself. The ad network will also likely want to sell your inventory along with other similar websites in their network in order to get you onto the advertising buy. This means that they may sell your inventory at a lower CPM as part of a larger advertising deal.

If you do choose to go down this route, it is worth your time to shop around a little to see what is out there.

There are no right or wrong answers for choosing one advertising sales channel over another. These are just some recommendations and guidelines about how you might get started.

I’d love to know what other questions that digital startups have about making money from online advertising. Please leave a comment if you have a question.

Image source: iStockPhoto.com


4 Ideas for an Afterlife for the Sears “Zombie Shopper” Campaign

screenshot of Sears Zombie Shopper account on Twitter

Who would have guessed that Zombies would turn out to be such excellent brand advocates? Recently, Sears.com created an Avatar called “ZombieShopper” on Twitter to promote their Halloween social media campaign.  It was a great attempt at revitalizing their brand to speak to a younger audience.  They succeeded at creating a lot of buzz from the campaign.  Even though it was a short-lived campaign, the results seem strong enough to hint that there are opportunities to continue the dialogue – even if Halloween is over. The question remains – will Sears continue to innovate and build on the attention that they received?  Sears.com has a unique opportunity to continue to ride the success of the “Zombie Shopper” campaign as popularity for vampires dies out and zombie interest rises in pop culture – for example via the mega movie hit Zombieland and the new AMC TV show The Walking Dead.

Here’s a review of the campaign’s online buzz to date – plus suggestions for keeping it alive:

(1) The Avatar “zombieshopperTwitter account received almost 1,000 followers in the month that the campaign ran in October.
Their actual reach was over 8,000 followers according to TweetReach: http://tweetreach.com/reach?q=zombieshopper. That’s pretty amazing to get such a quick surge of followers in such a short period of time for an unknown brand/Twitter username. No Tweets have been sent since Halloween – did the Zombie just die?  Why wouldn’t he continue to speak with us and live on? As I mentioned earlier, zombie TV shows like AMC’s The Walking Dead are gaining in popularity.  This is a huge opportunity for Sears to continue the conversation with ZombieShopper aficionados.

(2) According to Google Insights for Search, the campaign received a 525% higher search volume relative to the search volume for the shopping category overall on Google during the peak of the campaign – just before Halloween on October 25, 2010. But search volume died off, no pun intended, because Sears didn’t continue the dialogue after October 31st.

3)  Over 41,400 blogs and articles have been written about the campaign – based on recent search results for the term “Sears Zombie Shopper Campaign” on Google. Perhaps “ZombieShopper” should also have a blog to talk about what happened on Halloween night and where he went afterwards?

(4) Their uploaded YouTube viral videos received almost 200,000 views to date via their YouTube channel. Could they continue the videos to show what happened to the fitness instructor?  Where did the zombies go after Halloween?

I am aware that some of my suggestions are purely selfish as I am already missing the Tweets from @ZombieShopper. Hopefully, his Tweets will be resurrected and we can continue our Twitter relationship. Please share your thoughts and insights about this campaign.

Here’s a link to my favourite viral video for the Sears.com “Zombie Shopper” campaign:

Don’t be Afraid to Make a Turkey of Yourself

Photo of me in a turkey costume - 2nd from right

Second Harvest "Turkey Run" at the Toronto Scotiabank Marathon

I’ve been told that one of the secrets to successful networking is to show that you are vulnerable.  If you don’t let people know that you need their help and ask for it, you’ll never get anywhere.  I recently made the brave decision to become a freelancer. So, I’ve spent the past few weeks contacting people that I’ve previously worked with to find out how I can help them with their business and/or find out if they know anyone else who I might want to speak with? My goal is to talk to anyone who will listen and who might want to give me some advice.

So far, I’ve been overwhelmed by the amount of people who have offered to help by either sitting down to talk over coffee or by introducing me to someone else who might be a great contact.  People truly do want to help you if you give them the chance.  As a result, I have met some very interesting and inspiring people and I feel extremely grateful to all of them.

I used to shy away from networking because I was afraid of making a fool of myself but now my mantra is “always be networking”.  What do you have to lose? You just never know who you might meet and everyone has a great story to tell.  You might even make some new friends along the way. I figure, if I can dress up in a turkey costume and run 5K in front of thousands of people, I can definitely call someone up and ask them to go for coffee and chat.  This week, I am staying open to all possibilities!